Selah and The Spades review – a bipartisan satire Trumped

Early on in Tayarisha Poe’s debut feature, the protagonist looks into the camera and confidently laments, “Cover your shoulders, cover your legs, because they can’t tell boys to keep it in their pants.” They are taught to change themselves for the sake of other’s biological hormones they can’t control; the contempt of the very accepted social norm of appeasing anyone but themselves sets the overall tone for Selah and The Spades. That titular character, Selah, is played with great, even brooding moxie by Lovie Simone (Greenleaf), who carries the film up until the play it all too safe finale.

Poe’s script is a character study set is a highly stylized Juvenalian satire (so much so, it’s sometimes like looking at an overtly specific Tumblr page) about today’s political climate in a realistic setting — high school. Now, on the surface, this has been done before in films like Heathers and Cruel Intentions but aspires to a much higher plane to be taken seriously, like Alan Payne’s Election. With the current administration’s penchant for more visceral than ever before bipartisan politics, attacks on their opponents, and including their own, makes Selah feel almost fresh, even relevant instead of tired. The satirization of the ones in power (Simone) and the idealists (Wetlands’ Celeste O’Connor) and the ones just trying to survive (When They See Us Emmy-award winner Jharrel Jerome) crackles with bitter wit and a smart story; operating on varying levels that combines components of the social movements #MeToo and Black Lives Matter that go hand in hand.

Selah and the Spades has several interesting character studies that still tend to be rare on streaming platforms, but has an issue in that Simone’s Selah represents one of few potential female anti-heroes streaming anywhere today that the film doesn’t fully embrace.  Every film doesn’t need to redeem their characters. In fact, I would argue it would have been a much stronger film because of it.

The fatal flaw is here though is the safe way the film wraps up its story, losing its nerve, and lacking a killer instinct that the film really needed.  There is something uneven about it that feels unnatural, like an exit strategy for sequels or launch for a possible Amazon Prime television series with the stars attached — which could have still been accomplished with a touch more creativity without sacrificing the completion of a greater ideal. At the very least, a life goes on ending that didn’t need to bring everyone together.

After all, bipartisan politics’ job isn’t to compromise a belief, it’s to win it.

We are fast becoming the number one independent website for streaming coverage. Please support Ready Steady Cut today. Secure its future — we need you!

Become a Patron!

For more recaps, reviews and original features covering the world of entertainment, why not follow us on Twitter and like our Facebook page?

M.N. Miller

M.N. Miller has been a film and television writer for Ready Steady Cut since August of 2018 and is patiently waiting for the next Pearl Jam album to come out.