Echoes season 1 – who is Gina McCleary?

By Adam Lock
Published: August 19, 2022 (Last updated: November 10, 2023)
View all

This article, “who is Gina McCleary” contains spoilers regarding the Netflix limited series Echoes season 1.

Access the archive of recaps, reviews, and news for Echoes. 

Echoes focuses on the double lives of identical twins Gina and Leni McCleary. Over the course of the series, the sisters swap lives and identities on numerous occasions. Sometimes it is unclear who is who and the twins imply that they don’t even know themselves after all this deception. I’ll try to keep this biography solely focused on the real Gina at all times, but again, it is a confusing minefield to say the least.

Who is Gina McCleary in Echoes season 1?

Played by Michelle Monaghan, Gina is the straight-haired twin, who lives in Los Angeles. She has made a successful career for herself as an author, mining a bibliography from her childhood trauma and her unique perspective as an identical twin. The series opens with Gina living it up in the Hollywood Hills, married to an equally successful man called Charlie Davenport. Together they share an idyllic existence. Later it is revealed that the woman we believe to be Gina is in fact Leni, with the twins swapping lives on a yearly basis. The real Gina is all these things I’ve mentioned above and the one who crafted that lifestyle. It just happens to be Leni’s turn to play the writer role as the show kick starts.

As children, the twins were inseparable and impossible to tell apart. Only their mother knew the difference, Gina was the more emotional of the two. They swapped clothing in those early days, for mischievous pranks and to test the waters. One of these times, Claudia was pushed and became wheelchair bound due to the fall. Gina took the blame for this accident, but it was Leni that actually pushed her. Gina was from then on seen as Bad Gina and the troubled one of the two.

In their teenage years, the twins made friends with Jack. Gina loved him, but Leni was the more confident twin and started dating Jack. Gina was jealous and heartbroken by this betrayal. They eventually shared Jack without his knowledge, but Gina would pursue a different lover. Gina fell madly in love with biker Dylan instead. The two made love in an abandoned church and Leni set fire to it out of her own deep-seated jealousy. Leni manipulated the situation, forcing Dylan to flee and Gina to mistrust her boyfriend from that point onwards.

Dylan was never to be seen again and the twins were questioned, but no one took ownership of the fire, even though a man died in the arson. Gina left town to study in LA. She had a breakdown and started to see therapist Charlie. She wrote a book called Echoes during her senior year and married her therapist. Gina got pregnant, but miscarried. This devastating event forever changed her life, only worsened by Leni’s perfect pregnancy and transition into motherhood.

Leni hated parenting though and wished for a new life, she suggested the twins switching as adults, so Gina could experience motherhood and Leni could escape for a while. The switching worked well for years, but Leni began to become controlling and interfered in Gina’s life. Gina planned her own escape in secret. She then discovered that Charlie knew about the twin’s switcheroo, but he had chosen not to say anything. Gina gathered some funds together and readied for the swap-over. Gina became Leni, returning to Mount Echo.

At Mount Echo, she was reunited with Dylan, who had returned to town after all those years. She tried to rekindle their romance as Leni, but Dylan hated Leni for forcing him to leave in the first place. Gina owned up and explained the whole sorry tale to Dylan and they started their relationship again. They planned to leave together and when Gina fell pregnant again, they sped up the operation. Their scheme went to plan and fake Leni went missing under suspicious circumstances. They had a fake passport and cash at the ready for their clean getaway, but the conniving Leni ruined their plans. She stole their items and stabbed Dylan to death.

Gina’s return to Mount Echo unearthed many secrets, but ended in pure heartache for the twin. Her life was destroyed by the woman who was supposed to be her closest ally. She started a new life in Kansas, where hopefully she could leave all her troubles behind. Although, the writers hint at a bitter ending, with Gina returning to settle some scores. Do you believe Gina is back or is Leni up to her old tricks again? Please comment below.

You can watch this series with a subscription to Netflix.

Netflix, Streaming Service
View all