Tell Me Lies Season 1, Episode 5 Recap – “Merry F*cking Christmas”

By Jonathon Wilson
Published: September 21, 2022 (Last updated: 3 hours ago)
View all
Tell Me Lies Season 1, Episode 5 Recap - "Merry F*cking Christmas"
Tell Me Lies season 1, episode 5 - "Merry F*cking Christmas" (Credit - Hulu)




The fifth episode stays in a similar form to the previous episodes. Although much of “Merry F*cking Christmas” features Lucy and Stephen separately, it’s great to uncover more of their family relationships.

It’s December 2007 at the start of episode 5 of Tell Me Lies season 1, and Lucy is with Max. But she quickly ditches him to spend more time with Stephen. With the Christmas holiday coming up, Lucy and Stephen have to prepare not to see each other for a while.

When Stephen returns home, he goes to see his Mom, who’s in bed with a migraine. But after she hears him come in, she gets Stephen to come and say hi. As Lucy returns home, she learns that she’s got a place in the writing scheme. But the mood soon turns sour when James arrives with flowers.

During a drive with his Mom, Stephen gets into a heated debate over whether or not a flower shop worker is pretty. Later, while the family is out for dinner, Stephen’s father also eats at the restaurant.

While the children want to go home, their Mom doesn’t want to leave. Shortly afterward, Stephen’s Dad says that she has to stop doing this, and he quickly leaves with his pregnant partner. It soon becomes clear that his Mom had purposely arranged the dinner so they would bump into Stephen’s father. Stephen’s Mom attempts to divert blame by saying that it was Stephen who chose to go to the restaurant.

Lucy calls Stephen, and they both bond over their f*cked-up families. Because of the latest developments in his family, Stephen cancels his plan to meet up with Lucy. Moments later, Lucy booty calls Max.

When Lucy leaves her family to go to “Lydia’s,” although she’s most likely to see Max, it disappoints her Mom, C.J. As Lucy and Ma hang out, Diana arrives at Stephen’s house unannounced. While in bed with Max, Lucy opens up about her issues with her Mom.

Tell Me Lies Season 1, Episode 5

Tell Me Lies season 1, episode 5 – “Merry F*cking Christmas” (Credit – Hulu)

She reveals that as her Dad was dying, her Mom was f*cking James. However, her Mom has no idea that Lucy knows, and this makes it clear why Lucy feels so much resentment towards her Mom. After listening to her story, Max asks Lucy whether she could be depressed. Lucy, however, does not want to put a label on it.

Afterward, an upset Lydia calls up Lucy, and Lucy punches Rob for her. Towards the end of the show, Lucy’s Mom tells her that she never wonders if people think “if she is sad enough,” as she knows she is. Lucy attends a memorial for Macy, and Stephen goes to see his Dad. Stephen tells his Dad that he needs a favor. And that favor is to sign a letter for his sister so she can attend college.

A bit of a low-key ending, but that pretty much sums up the show. Overall, a very good episode!

Do you have any thoughts on Tell Me Lies Season 1, Episode 5? I’d love to know—comment below.


Hulu, Streaming Service, TV, Weekly TV
View all